There are a number of reasons policy decisions are not more evidence-based but three predominate.
The first is simply that the research has not been conducted; for many important policy decisions it is impossible to be evidence-based because the evidence is currently not there.
Three other elements of the policy-making environment need to be borne in mind.
Policy-making is generally extremely fast by academic standards.
The first is the relatively limited range of things policymakers can do.
They can exhort; in some cases they can legislate; most commonly they deploy resources but this means moving resources from one priority to another rather than creating new resource.Barriers include the evidence not being there; lack of demand by policymakers; academics not producing rigorous, relevant papers within the timeframe of the policy cycle. Academics underestimate the speed of the policy process, and publish excellent papers after a policy decision rather than good ones before it.To be useful in policy, papers must be at least as rigorous about reporting their methods as for other academic uses.The second follows from the fact that their main lever is moving constrained resources around and choosing between different ratios of financial allocation; they tend to think like economists or be advised by them, and economics is the training for many policymakers, whether civil servants or politicians.This does not mean good economic analysis is essential to influence policy (although it certainly helps), but good policymakers will always be asking the question ‘what is the opportunity cost of this new initiative? Policymakers also therefore can be more numerate than scientists often give them credit for, and have access to well trained statisticians.Policy decisions are invariably weakened when they do not take account of the best current knowledge.Incorporating relevant research findings into policy and practice should therefore be central to the aims of those undertaking practically oriented health research, including in the basic and social sciences.Papers which are as simple as possible (but no simpler) are most likely to be taken up in policy.Most policy questions have many scientific questions, from different disciplines, within them.What makes a good scientific policy paper, defined as a paper likely to influence and improve policy decisions based on science?The starting point for any piece of communication, and a scientific paper is a form of communication, is: who is the audience?
Comments Writing Policy Papers
Writing a Position Paper
If you are writing a paper for a sociology professor/TA obviously your analysis would be different from what it would be if you were writing for an economics.…
Writing a Policy Memo - Organizing Academic Research.
With this in mind, you should not approach writing a policy memo like you would an academic research paper. Yes, there are certain commonalities in how the.…
Current Public Policy Papers Advocacy ACP
ACP public policy papers summarize and dissect published research and discussion on current issues involving clinical practice, medical education, bioethics.…
Writing Position Papers - Study Guides and Strategies
Techniques and strategies for writing position papers, as well as their elements.…
Writing Effective Public Policy Papers
Writing Effective. Public Policy Papers. A Guide for Policy Advisers in Central and Eastern Europe. Eóin Young and Lisa Quinn.…
Writing Policy Analysis and Proposal Papers - EDU 507 Policy.
Aug 14, 2019. EDU 507 Policy and Law in Education Writing Policy Analysis and Proposal Papers. This guide is to support Soka graduate students in their.…
Writing Policy Briefs - JPI Urban Europe
What are policy briefs? • It is a concise summary of a particular issue. • It presents the policy options to deal with it. • *It offers a recommendation on the best.…
White Papers and Briefing Books - Projects at Harvard
Papers are common not only to policy and politics, but also in business and technical fields. In. It is a first step in clarifying your ideas before writing the policy.…
PDF Review of Writing Effective Policy Papers Guide Mehdi.
Review of the book Information about the book AUTHOR Eóin Young and Lisa Quinn TITLE Writing Effective Public Policy Papers. SUBTITLE A Guide for.…
What makes an academic paper useful for health policy.
Dec 17, 2015. To be useful in policy, papers must be at least as rigorous about. are often forgotten by those who think they are writing for policymakers.…